GoodKibble
Discover Foods
GoodKibble
Discover FoodsRecalls
Home/Best/Best Puppy Food in 2026

Best Puppy Food in 2026

Ranked by our scoring methodology across 152 puppy-specific products

Puppies need higher protein and fat than adult dogs to support growth. We scored every puppy food in our database across protein adequacy, fat-to-protein ratios, ingredient quality, and more. These are the top 10. Read our full methodology.
#1
ORIJEN Amazing Grains, Puppy Large
Orijen

ORIJEN Amazing Grains, Puppy Large

92
Excellent
GoodKibble Score
Protein 43.2%Fat 18.2%Carbs 26.1%Chicken

High protein (43.2% DMB), chicken-based, natural preservatives only, omega-3 present earned this a 92/100 score.

Full Review
#2
Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE Puppy Chicken and Oatmeal
Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE Puppy Chicken and Oatmeal

90
Excellent
GoodKibble Score
Protein 40%Fat 17.8%Carbs 28.9%Chicken

High protein (40% DMB), chicken-based, natural preservatives only, omega-3 present earned this a 90/100 score.

Full Review
#3
Wellness Core Grain Free Small Breed Puppy Turkey Recipe
Wellness

Wellness Core Grain Free Small Breed Puppy Turkey Recipe

92
Excellent
GoodKibble Score
Protein 42.2%Fat 18.9%Carbs 25.6%Turkey

High protein (42.2% DMB), turkey-based, natural preservatives only, omega-3 present earned this a 92/100 score.

Full ReviewCheck Price on Amazon
#4
Wellness Core Grain Free Puppy Chicken Recipe
Wellness

Wellness Core Grain Free Puppy Chicken Recipe

88
Great
GoodKibble Score
Protein 40%Fat 17.8%Carbs 28.3%Chicken

High protein (40% DMB), chicken-based, natural preservatives only, omega-3 present earned this a 88/100 score.

Full ReviewCheck Price on Amazon
#5
Blue Buffalo Wilderness Puppy Chicken with Wholesome Grains
Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Puppy Chicken with Wholesome Grains

90
Excellent
GoodKibble Score
Protein 40%Fat 17.8%Carbs 28.9%Chicken

High protein (40% DMB), chicken-based, natural preservatives only, omega-3 present earned this a 90/100 score.

Full Review
#6
ORIJEN Amazing Grains, Puppy
Orijen

ORIJEN Amazing Grains, Puppy

91
Excellent
GoodKibble Score
Protein 43.2%Fat 22.7%Carbs 21.6%Chicken

High protein (43.2% DMB), chicken-based, natural preservatives only, omega-3 present earned this a 91/100 score.

Full Review
#7
Challenger High-Protein Kibble for Large Breed Puppy Alpine Ranch Beef, Lamb & Pork
Nulo

Challenger High-Protein Kibble for Large Breed Puppy Alpine Ranch Beef, Lamb & Pork

90
Excellent
GoodKibble Score
Protein 35.6%Fat 15.6%Carbs 35.6%Beef

High protein (35.6% DMB), beef-based, natural preservatives only, omega-3 present earned this a 90/100 score.

Full ReviewCheck Price on Amazon
#8
Simply Nourish Source Puppy - High Protein, Chicken & Grain
Simply Nourish

Simply Nourish Source Puppy - High Protein, Chicken & Grain

84
Great
GoodKibble Score
Protein 40%Fat 16.7%Carbs 27.8%Chicken

High protein (40% DMB), chicken-based, natural preservatives only, omega-3 present earned this a 84/100 score.

Full Review
#9
Puppy Recipe
Acana

Puppy Recipe

83
Great
GoodKibble Score
Protein 35.2%Fat 21.6%Carbs 29.5%Chicken

High protein (35.2% DMB), chicken-based, natural preservatives only, omega-3 present earned this a 83/100 score.

Full ReviewCheck Price on Amazon
#10
MedalSeries Ancient Grains Puppy Turkey, Oats & Guinea Fowl Recipe
Nulo

MedalSeries Ancient Grains Puppy Turkey, Oats & Guinea Fowl Recipe

84
Great
GoodKibble Score
Protein 31.1%Fat 17.8%Carbs 38.3%Turkey

High protein (31.1% DMB), turkey-based, natural preservatives only, omega-3 present earned this a 84/100 score.

Full Review

How We Score

Every dog food in our database is scored 0-100 across eight categories: protein, fat, carbohydrates, fiber, protein source quality, preservatives, additives, and functional ingredients. We use dry matter basis (DMB) calculations to normalize nutrition across foods with different moisture levels. Rankings are based entirely on nutritional data and ingredient analysis — no brand pays for placement. Discover all 152 products in our database.

Related Rankings

Best Dog FoodBest Large Breed Dog FoodBest Grain-Free Dog FoodBrowse All 1,000+ Foods
GoodKibble
TermsPrivacyRecallsFAQ© 2026 GoodKibble. Not affiliated with any dog food brand.